OPINION
Development of liposomal drug formulations: quality attributes and methods for quality control
Scientific center for expert evaluation of medicinal products of the Ministry of health of the Russian Federation, Moscow
Correspondence should be addressed: Alexander A. Chaplenko
Shchukinskaya, 6 bl. 1, Moscow, 127051;
ur.dempxe@oknelpahc
Some of the major current challenges before the pharmaceutical industry are regulation of all pharmacokinetic parameters of a drug (absorption, distribution, clearance and biotransformation), ensuring its safety and selective action on target organs and other targets, minimization of undesirable reactions and side effects. Using nanostructured components in general and to deliver drugs to a given body part, organ or cell in particular is one of the trends that sees development today. Russian legislation does not describe the concepts of “nanopreparations” or “nanodrugs”; in reality, all drugs that are nanoparticles or contain them are considered to be such. This definition mainly applies to the drugs based on liposomes and micelles, where nanostructures enable transportation of the active pharmaceutical ingredient inside the body, prolong its absorption, increase stability, etc. Another case are drugs considered to be nanostructured due to the physicochemical characteristics of their active ingredients, an example of which are antianemic iron preparations that may contain iron (III) atoms stabilized by a carbohydrate complex, which defines their nanocolloidal structure. Currently, we are developing quality assessment and research guidelines applicable to drugs based on liposomes and micelles, as well as containing nanoparticles.
Features of the nanodrugs' compositions define the individual approaches to assessing their quality. For example, quality of liposomal preparations largely depends on their individual specific attributes (size of nanoparticles, surface morphology, surface charge), which can affect the following pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic properties in vivo:
- rate of release of the active ingredient from liposomes, a factor that has an effect on pharmacokinetics (PK) and pharmacodynamics (PD) and, consequently, drug's safety profile and efficacy;
- bioavailability of the active pharmaceutical ingredient in liposome, its biotransformation and clearance.
PK of the encapsulated active ingredient depends on that of the carrier, which is determined by the physicochemical properties of the nanoparticle material; interactions between the nanoparticle's components, active ingredient and biological environment (body) should also be taken into account.
We define nanodrugs as drugs that contain dendrimers, nanocrystals, micelles, liposomes and polymeric nanoparticles. Currently, liposome is one of the best-studied nanoparticles among those considered as effective carriers for various drugs. In the recent years, global pharmaceutical industry has developed and released over 20 liposomal drugs primarily used to treat cancer (Dauno Xome (Gilead, NeXstar), Doxil (Alza, Sequus), Couloux (Schering-Plow), Muocet (Elan, TLS)) and fungal infections (AmBisome, ABELSET (Gilead, NeXstar)) [1]. Specific capabilities related to transportation, translocation through histohematogenous barriers and cell membranes, as well as metabolic transformations, provide liposome-based drugs with unique properties that improve their PK.
This article summarizes and analyzes the data describing the use of various types of liposomes for drug delivery and defines the specifics of the liposome-based nanodrugs quality assessment.
Varieties of liposomes and their use by pharmaceutical industry
Liposomes are vesicles with a lipid bilayer built of amphiphilic molecules enclosing their contents. Recently, liposomes have evolved from a simple model that mimics cell membranes into an object of active research and practical application [2]. In the context of drug delivery, liposomes enable selective accumulation of the active ingredient in pathological lesions (tumors, inflamed tissues) due to their passive targeting ability. This ability is the results of the difference in distance between capillary cells in lesions/tumors and normal tissue: the former, which is 210 to 1000 nm, is significantly greater than the latter, which is approximately 40 nm. Thus, liposomes less than 200 nm in size cannot escape the bloodstream anywhere except the lesions (with the exception of the brain, where tumors typically have pores of 7–100 nm [3, 4]), and the active pharmaceutical ingredient, which can be toxic, is unlikely to contaminate anything but the target. For example, liposomal doxorubicin is 2–3 times less toxic than the solution of this drug [5].
Using target (endothelial) protein antibodies, which are specific to vessels of various organs, allows manifold improvement of precision of the nanoparticle-enabled delivery of active pharmaceutical ingredients and DNA [6–9].
To date, various researchers have described liposome-based preparations carrying a plethora of active ingredients, X-ray and scintigraphic tracers, toxins, peptides, proteins and nucleic acids. The overwhelming majority of studies in this field has to do with anticancer drugs (most often, anthracycline-based) [8]. There are five types of liposomes, different in composition and action in vivo, that the researchers preferred, namely: simple liposomes; sterically stabilized liposomes; directed liposomes (immunoliposomes); cationic liposomes; liposomes sensitive to physical and chemical stimuli, such as temperature, light, and changes in pH [2, 10] (tab. 1).
When progress in biotechnology and genetic engineering allowed developing a new generation of drugs, such as recombinant proteins, peptides (biotechnological drugs), drugs based on nucleic acids (gene therapy drugs), liposomes acquired a special significance due to the susceptibility of these medicines to chemical and enzymatic hydrolysis [8, 39–41]. In gene therapy, liposome nanocontainers may carry a plasmid with a therapeutic gene sequence, antisense oligonucleotides or small interfering RNAs [42-44]. The volume of the liposomes allows them to contain genes of various sizes [45]. Vector molecules attached to the outer surface of the liposomes target delivery, a mechanism similar to that used for cytotoxic drugs and paramagnetic contrast agents.
When liposomes are used as DNA vaccines, they hold the antigen in their capsule and double as an immunomodulator [46, 47]. In one of the studies, S-antigen sequence of HBV (pRc / CMV HBS) enclosed in cationic liposomes was used as a DNA vaccine [47]. Balb/c mice received a vaccine of 10 μg of plasmid DNA (i.m., per mouse) twice on days 0 and 21. After administration of the native HBsAg, the levels of detectable cytokines in spleens of mice immunized with the liposome-based preparation were 4 times higher than those registered in intact mice and animals vaccinated with DNA, which suggests a possibility of using this liposomal construct as a Hepatitis B vaccine.
Both cationic or anionic liposomes and those with a neutral surface charge can be loaded with DNA. Neutral liposomes circulate in the bloodstream for a much longer period of time than the charged ones; moreover, their advantages are lesser toxicity and non-specific persorption in organs and tissues. However, it is much harder to load them with DNA. In case of passive loading, which is a plain emulsification of lipid components in the presence of DNA, only 10% of the total amount of DNA gets into the liposomes. There are special techniques that allow increasing the number to 40%, but, as a rule, they also increase the size of the liposomes [45]. Charged liposomes can be loaded with more DNA, which is their key advantage. However, cationic and anionic liposomes have higher levels toxicity and non-specific penetration into organs and tissues than neutral liposomes.
Specifics of the liposome-based drugs quality and production control
The main stages of production of liposomal drug formulations and the controlled parameters thereof are listed below [48].
1) Lipid film production and its dispersion/degradation. Controlled parameters: amount of residual organic solvents in the lipid film; active pharmaceutical ingredient integration rate and size of the liposomes after lipid film dispersion; stability; pH value.
2) Production of liposomes of the required size, separating the non-integrated active ingredient, sterilization by filtration. Controlled parameters: amount of the integrated active pharmaceutical ingredient; size of the liposomes; concentration of the lipid components; stability; pH value.
3) Lyophilization. Controlled parameters: residual moisture; stability and percentage of drug integration into the liposomes after lyophilisate rehydration.
The above-listed stages of the technological process allow a conclusion that the critical liposome-based drug quality checks imply determination of its crucial physicochemical properties; therefore, state registration applications for such formulations should provide the following information (figure).
The behavior of the active pharmaceutical ingredient in a physiological environment is one of the main parameters influencing the liposome-based drug's PK and PD. Therefore, for the purposes listed below it is necessary to develop reliable, validated methods of assessment of the active ingredient release in vitro.
– Monitoring of imitation of the active ingredient release from liposomes in the body; a test for "leakage" in vitro in the relevant environment under various conditions (e.g., in a certain range of temperatures and pH) can be conducted given there are grounds for that.
– Monitoring of stability in storage to ensure consistency of lots;
– Investigation of stability and review of the production process in the intended conditions of use.
tab. 2 provides an example of the certificate data (key parameters and quality indicators) describing liposomes [49, 50] used for delivery of the therapeutic genes' DNA.
We believe that, depending on the specific function of the liposomes (e.g., modification of the active ingredient's distribution by encapsulation in order to improve the safety profile), the following additional parameters should also be evaluated in the development of the drug:
– maintaining the integrity of the liposomal formulation in plasma;
– characteristics of the lipid bilayer phase transition process (transition temperature and enthalpy);
– determination of the surface charge of the liposomes;
– pH of the inner chamber of the liposomes filled by the pH gradient;
– if significant, determination of characteristics of the active pharmaceutical ingred
ient's physical state inside the liposome (e.g., formation of a precipitate for doxorubicin);
– distribution of the active ingredient (e.g., on the surface of liposomes, in the bilayer, internal environment, etc.);
– for conjugated (eg, pegylated) liposome-based preparations: the quality and purity of the pegylated starting material, molecular weight of the conjugated lipid and size distribution (dispersion), location of PEG on the surface, stability of the conjugate.
It is necessary to compile a list of tests each lot should routinely be subjected to. This list should be based on the parameters used to characterize the drug in accordance with the requirements described above.
Legal regulation of liposome-based drugs in the world
tab. 3 provides the examples of requirements regulator bodies from various countries of the world impose on the production, quality control, preclinical and clinical studies of liposome-based forms of drugs.
CONCLUSIONS
Liposome-based drug delivery systems give a drug designer control over the active ingredient's absorption and release parameters. As a rule, liposome-based drugs are less toxic, pose a lower risk of adverse reactions and allow delivering the active ingredient to the target part of the body. Innovative drugs containing liposomes conjugated with antibodies can be targeted with maximum effectiveness and release the active ingredient where needed. However, the more complex the drug's structure becomes, the more crucial stages its production acquires. Moreover, the list of parameters to control, those that determine the quality of the drug, grows. Evaluation of the liposomal fraction's physicochemical properties is added to the classic quality control methods: the shape, size, and charge of the particles are being assessed, as well as marker conjugation effectiveness and uniformity of distribution of the active ingredient. Key methods for estimating the liposome parameters make use of the optical effects: dynamic and laser light scattering, electron microscopy.